posts may contain Amazon affiliate links, which earn me a small commission when you buy (but doesn't cost you anything extra). Occasionally I receive free products and/or run sponsored posts—this will always be stated clearly in the post. Thank you for supporting this blog.

This website contains some quotations, excerpts, and screen clips from copyrighted material. These uses fall well within the copyright doctrine of "Fair Use".
Friday, February 25, 2011

Dark Onion Rye

This month the Bread Baking Babes are celebrating their 3rd anniversary and reminiscing about some of their favorites loaves from the past three years (you can see a complete list at any of the Babes sites, like my friend Natashya's) and they have invited us to join them at the party. As long as we bake up a loaf from the list and bring it along.  Sounds reasonable.  After all, who likes to show up to a party empty-handed!?  The hardest part was plucking just one recipe from that astounding breadhead compilation!  I knew I wanted to choose one that would let me use Sally.  These days, that's a given.  She likes to be kept active.  Also, I was feeling in a rye-type of mood, so I went with the Dark Onion Rye from way back in June of '08.
Look at Sally!  I'm such a proud parent...
 Dark Onion Rye
adapted from The Sour Dough 
(originally a BBB challenge in June '08)
makes 1 loaf


In large bowl combine:
¾ c. rye flour
¾ c. bread flour
½ c. water
Cover and let mixture ferment 8-10 hours or overnight.
1½ Tbs. dark molasses (not Blackstrap, too bitter)
2 Tbs. honey
2 Tbs. unsalted butter, melted

Mix until smooth either by hand or in mixer w/ dough hook.

To sponge mixture add:
1¾ tsp. salt
1½ Tbs. freeze dried or sweated fresh onions
2 heaping tsp. caraway seeds
1 c. rye flour
½ c. bread flour

Knead together until it comes into a bit of a shaggy ball.

In a separate bowl, whisk together:
½ c. rye flour
½ c. bread flour

***Be very careful at this step. Don't add too much flour here!!!  I think I got a bit excited and added too much, resulting in an extremely stiff dough.  You may not need more than a half cup of the mixture, so add with a light hand.***

If using a mixer, fit it with the dough hook and on low-speed, add ¼ cup at a time until dough forms ball that pulls away from the bowl and is firm but still slightly tacky to the touch.  Or else, work it in with your hands to get the same results.

On a floured counter, knead dough for ~2-4 minutes and let rest for 15 minutes. Knead again until dough feels elastic and tacky, although it should not stick to your hands. If it does stick to your hands, knead in a bit of additional rye flour until dough is firm but ever so slightly tacky.
In large, lightly greased covered bowl, let dough rise until almost double, ~4 hours.

This bread works best if formed into a round. Gently deflate risen dough (well, there was not a whole lot to deflate, but I went with it) and gather into a ball. Set dough seam side up, in a very well floured brotform or on a floured board, and cover loosely.  Let rise until dough doubles in size, ~2-3 hours.  Actually, I think I'd have to recommend just going  free-form, as the dough doesn't seem to get enough rise (up or out)  to fill up a brotform.
Place a baking stone (or tiles) in the center of oven and preheat oven to 400° F during last 20 minutes of rising time.
Gently unmold risen loaf onto a flat baking sheet prepared with cornmeal dusted parchment paper or onto a prepared peel. You may slash the loaf is you wish. Mist top of loaf with water and gently slide bread into the oven and bake at 400° for 20 mintues.
Turn oven down to 375° F and bake for another 25-30 minutes or until inside temperature of loaf reaches 200° F.
Let bread cool for 4 - 6 hours before slicing. This is very important as rye breads will turn to a gummy mess if they are sliced before completely cool.
*My notes: I used 100% All-Natural Stone-Ground Rye Flour throughout the recipe.  The original recipe called for both dark and light rye flours, but since I already had this type, I just subbed it all in for the two varieties.  The dough smells fantastic both in it's unbaked form and while it is baking.  Oniony goodness!  While the loaf is extremely firm and dense, it is also full of flavor.  Great for toasting.
submitting to:
Bread Baking Buddies in conjunction w/ the Bread Baking Babes 3rd Anniversary Party! hosted this month at My Kitchen in Half Cups.

Bread Baking Day #37 - Bread made with sponge or pre-ferment (last day of submission March 1st, 2011) BYOB

Would you like to comment?

  1. se ve con una pinta estupenda el plato. Saludos

  2. Marvellous and damn pretty looking bread..

  3. Is it officially the first of Sally's bread? amazing! And looks really tasty. Since when I live in Germany, there is so much good bread on sale that I have left my bread baking obsession in the back row, but this post and the other ones about your sourdough starter.. I miss baking bread, yes!

  4. Thanks for another one Heather. I had made Rye bread a long time back (before blogging days). For some reason the caraway seeds made them a bit bitter. Scared of making Rye bread now.

  5. Great baking Heather! Thanks for baking along with us.
    Very brave to use just the darker rye, can imagine it will yield a denser loaf but even more yummy rye-ness.

  6. Beautiful loaf, rye bread is delicious, and toasted especially.

  7. I think you need start your own bread bakery soon!!

  8. I love rye for sandwiches, beautiful loaf of bread Heather (as always)!

  9. This rye loaf looks so delicious! I definitely need to try my hand at a rye soon!

  10. I think this bread helps the world go round.

  11. My husband would kill for me to make this...lovely lovely

  12. This bread must be so fantastic freshly baked, yum!

  13. Can i ever make bread ? I don't know .. till then i have to satisfy myself with your bread posts .. :)

  14. Yum this looks like some delicious bread!!!

  15. Their list of breads is definitely impressive. And makes me want to get in the kitchen and knead til I drop. I love this loaf! I need to purchase some rye flour. Soon.

  16. thank you for linking you have done a lovely job
    I have never tried this

  17. oh this sounds wonderful! i want a slice with a fat slab of butter.

  18. always enjoy your bread recipes :-)


  19. I love rye bread--this looks fabulous and it's good to see Sally did her job well. ;-)

  20. wow, looks so lovely, very new for me.

  21. Now that's bakn' Bread! Sally's a keeper for sure.

    Thanks a million for baking with us!

    The only thing wrong with your loaf ... you didn't save me a slice. I really loved this bread ... when I get a kitchen again, it's on my do again list!

  22. Ooooooh. Now I'm thinking I should have chosen to make the dark onion rye again.

    I know. There's nothing stopping me ... aside from the fact that there's nobody resembling Sally here. And after I accidentally on purpose (shshhh don't tell) murdered our starter, I swore I'd never have another pet again.

    Mmmmmm, I'm remembering the truly great Reuben sandwiches we made with Mary's Dark onion rye. I think I may need to reconsider my vow.

  23. Sally is gorgeous...and so is the bread. Look at that wonderful crust! Glad you brought it to the party...yum! Thanks for baking with the Babes!

  24. Another beautiful bread! You must be so-o-o proud of Sally!