posts may contain Amazon affiliate links, which earn me a small commission when you buy (but doesn't cost you anything extra). Occasionally I receive free products and/or run sponsored posts—this will always be stated clearly in the post. Thank you for supporting this blog.

This website contains some quotations, excerpts, and screen clips from copyrighted material. These uses fall well within the copyright doctrine of "Fair Use".
Sunday, April 24, 2011

Chewy, Amazing, Addicting, 100% SOURDOUGH BAGELS

It's the little things that amaze me.  Seemingly trivial things that for all I know, nobody pays attention to but me.  Take for instance bagel dough smelling like bagels (...actual bagels!).  Whodathunkit?  Maybe it's due to the fact that I've never successfully made bagels from scratch before.  Although, I've actually only ever tried one time before.  With a no-knead dough that was entirely too wet to be destined for the title "bagel".  This was before I read something that would forever change the way I looked at the science of bagel-making.  That would be an article from Susan of Wild Yeast comprised of opinions that were 100% hers...and bagels that were 100% sourdough.  Is it possible for opinions that are 100% somebody else's to be 100% mine, as well?  Because employing her (fabulously) sassy opinions and (absolutely) amazing instructions produced THE BEST BAGELS IN THE ENTIRE WORLD.  No really.  The.  Best.

While I recommend that you go over and read them for yourself, I am going to mention a few points that were KEY in helping me finally "get" how bagels were made.  First off, the dough shouldn't be too wet and it should be STRONG!  Susan likened it to a new tire...and by that I pictured a new inner tube...and went for that feeling.  It totally worked.  Also, she insists that the rope method is the only way to form bagels.  I agree, this makes a beautiful, hand-crafted poke method for me.  Go check out what else Susan says about making perfect bagels...chewy and amazing and 100% sourdough.  Hmmmm, does this make me sound like a stalker?
100% Sourdough Bagels
recipe from Wild Yeast 
yield: 8 bagels

    349 grams high-gluten flour (or 339 g flour plus 10 g vital wheat gluten)
    121 grams cold water
    28 grams milk powder
    16.4 grams  brown sugar (use non-diastatic malt powder if you have it instead or barley malt syrup)
    10.1 grams (1 2/3 teaspoons) salt
    301 grams active 100%-hydration sourdough starter
    1 Tbs. baking soda for boiling

    Whisk the flour, malt (or brown sugar), milk powder, and salt together in the bowl of a stand mixer.  Add the starter and water to this mixture.  Mix on low speed to combine.  Continue to mix until the dough is very smooth and very strong...and seems almost rubbery.  This took ~6 minutes in my mixer...but it could vary a bit in yours.

    Turn the dough out onto an unfloured counter and work a few turns by hand. Form the dough into a smooth ball; the surface should feel satiny and tight.

    Cover the dough loosely with plastic wrap or a towel and let it rest for 10 minutes.

    Divide the dough into 8 pieces of (~100 g each). Form each piece into a ball. Cover and let rest for another 10 minutes.

    Line a sheet tray with parchment or a silpat, then dust it generously with semolina.

One by one, roll each ball into a long, thick cylinder that is ~8"-10" long.  Keep the width even throughout (don't taper the ends)I've decided that I like making mine a bit longer, ~10"-12".  My hands are probably bigger.

Wrap the length around your hand and overlap the ends by ~2".  Roll this section on the counter to meld the ends together a bit.  (A helpful note from Susan: if dough is a little dry, give it a quick spritz of water with a fine spray bottle before shaping...this will help it roll easier and help the ends stick together).  I didn't need to do that this time, but each batch is different.
Place the bagels on the prepared sheet trays and cover with plastic wrap. If your bagel had a seem on it, make sure that seem is on bottom. Proof for about 4 hours at warm room temperature, until the bagels look and feel a bit puffy.
When 4 hours is up, transfer the whole tray to the refrigerator for 4–8 hours.

Preheat oven to 425° F.  Put a large pot of water over high heat and bring to a boil

Place a clean dishtowel on your work surface and place a wire rack on top of it.  Remove bagels from refrigerator (see photo 1).  Lightly dust the semolina from the bottoms and place them on the rack (see photo 2).

When the water boils vigorously, add the baking soda. 

Gently lower a few bagels at a time into the boiling water.  Cook for 20 seconds (by which time they should be floating).  If they float immediately, be sure to turn them after 10 seconds so both sides get the full benefit of the boiling water.
Lift them out with a strainer or slotted spatula and place back on wire rack.  Repeat with remaining dough.  Let them sit on the rack for at least 30 seconds (see photo 3) before placing them back on the semolina-dusted, lined sheet tray.

Once they are all back on the tray (see photo 4), slide them into the oven.  Once the oven door is shut, lower heat to 400° F.  Bake until golden, ~24-26 minutes...opening the oven door very briefly half way through to vent any built-up steam.
Put that wire rack back to use by cooling the bagels on it.
Oh yes, and my little source of amazement happened at the specific step where the bagels were lifted from the boiling water and left to sit for 30 seconds before transferring back to the baking sheet (ie...right around photo 3 up there).  I leaned over so that my nose was directly over the damp dough...and inhaled deeply...and almost teared up.  It smelled like freshly baked bagels.  I don't why this was so pivotal or even surprising to me.  But like I said, it's the little things.
Okay, since I scheduled this post a few days ahead of time, I have already made these bagels again.  I am addicted.  I wanted to reiterate their perfection.  I'm in love with how chewy they are.  If you take a big bite (or a small one, for that matter), then pull it back and look at it, you'll see the bagel "springing" back up.  Plus, the beauty of the "sour".  Ahhhh.  I'm in love.  Oh.  And you wanna know how to make them even more amazing?  Shmear them with cultured cream cheese and then top that with mango butter.   'Scuse me...the toaster is calling my name.

I am sharing this post with:
BYOB-badge midnight maniac meatless monday just another meatless monday veganmondays

Would you like to comment?

  1. I'll have mine slathered with lots of cream cheese :) They look very chewy and delicious! I've never ventured into bagel making, but definitely one of these days.

  2. Thanks a lot for the step by step photos. i had never venture into bagel making but your comments and instructions make me want to bake them.

    They look great.


  3. Sour Dough and bagels. Two of my favorite things! Yum!

    Simply Kate

  4. Your bagels sound amazing. And they look fantastic! Wow!

  5. You're totally allowed to be a stalker when it means you end up with bagels that look like this. These would put NYC bagels to shame!

  6. straight sexy bagels! Nice work, time for me to get on board!

  7. These look fabulous. I am not brave enough to make my own but these are amazing. ;-)

  8. Given that I come from NYC (arguably the bagel capitol of the USA) and live in MN (not even close to the top ten bagel cities), this is coming at a time when I have been yearning for a real bagel. Have yet to make them... but with your tasty results - I am gearing up.

  9. What beautiful bagels! They make for a fantastic breakfast...or any time, really. Hope you had a wonderful Easter!

  10. Girl...I'm impressed! I remember way back in the day when you were nervous of the yeasty beasties ~ Look at you now! Sourdough AND bagels? You rock!

  11. Perfectly made have done an amazing work here.l

  12. Que buenos bagels, fantasticos.


  13. How great !Bagels are one of the things I miss from the US ! I understand you used a liquid starter, right ? Will try them !

  14. natalia...a starter at 100% hydration (is this what you meant by a liquid starter?). If you click on the words sourdough starter in the recipe, you will be taken to the starter that I used...just to double check =)

  15. I made some homemade bagels last week that I simply adored. I attribute the perfect chewy texture the the vital wheat gluten...

    I made them again after my first batch, and flavored them...cinnamon sugar was my favorite. I just sort of put a TBS of a cinnamon sugar mixture and kneaded it in before forming into a rope. I agree...rope method is the way to go!

    I have never made sourdough....but I can just imagine how super wonderful these are!

  16. Love sourdough! Those bagels must have tasted heavenly!

  17. Heather, They look amazing. No wonder your addicted. Who wouldn't be?

  18. my husband is the baker in the family and i'm currently begging him to make these for me. perhaps i will get brave and make them myself? either way, i need them!

  19. These sound like some great tips...I love bagels but they are something I have yet to prepare myself.

  20. Oh yum! I definitely have to try these! Fresh baked breads always amaze me - I'm much more about breads than desserts when it comes to baked goods - but I'm not a baker at all. If it can't go in my bread machine from start to finish it usually just isn't going to happening. Awesome job! :-)